ACHUKA

children's & YA recommendations on the go

  • News
    • Archived reviews
  • Illustrated
    • Graphic Novels
    • Meet An Illustrator
  • Fiction
    • Humour
    • Classics/Reissues
    • YA
  • Non-Fiction
  • Poetry & Tales
  • Gift
  • Links
  • About
    • ACHUKAstudio
    • Contact me
You are here: Home / BookOfTheDay / The Haunted Wood: A History of Childhood Reading by Sam Leith

The Haunted Wood: A History of Childhood Reading by Sam Leith

October 15, 2024 By achuka Leave a Comment

ACHUKA Non-Fiction Book of the Year 2024
ACHUKA Book of the Day 15 Oct 2024

Waterstones
Bookshop

“Sam Leith is the best kind of guide to this world in which we once wandered. He is fair-minded but terrifically opinionated; good on secondary sources without getting bogged down; excellent at analysing the technical merits of a story but not too grown-up to forget how he once listened to them.” Evening Standard
“Leith has synthesised a vast amount of material and produced a marvellously charming and enjoyable history for the general reader.” Literary Review
“Leith’s The Haunted Wood captures the magic of childhood reading and casts a spell of its own.” The Times
“A terrific book, full of high-grade lit-crit and undimmed personal enthusiasm.” Spectator

I have vivid memories of lying in bed on high summer nights, blinded by hay fever, the light still bright outside, a book on the bedspread beside me (it’s always a hardback in plain green boards for some reason), pleading with my eyes to clear for long enough to read one more chapter.

Looking back, I was an avid reader, but didn’t particularly think of myself as such. Given a choice between playing outside and sitting indoors with a book I would always choose the former. But weather, hay fever, poor circulation on snowy days, and dark winter evenings often took that choice away.

I never saw my parents read anything other than the daily paper, but I knew they did. They read in bed. My mother read crime novels in green Penguin editions (these being just about the only books in our house), my dad popular fiction from the library.

They didn’t read to me, or at least not in ways that I remember, and made no efforts to encourage me to read particular books. My mother took me to the library regularly where I was given free rein.

At the school I attended, a small semi-detached corner house prep school in Wembley, with a room layout very similar to the house I live in now, the library, such as it was, consisted of a couple of shelves of titles in the equivalent of what we call our ‘breakfast room’. Daily bottles of milk were served from the kitchen just beyond it, a moment in the day I dreaded. Visits to the ‘library’ were not much more to my taste, as I rarely, if ever, read the books I selected.

The irony is that this heavily curated library probably included most of the books mentioned in Sam Leith’s wonderfully readable The Haunted Wood.

So, what did children like me, coming of reading age in the late 1950s, choose to read if it was not books from the canon as surveyed by The Haunted Wood? In my case, it was Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine mysteries, Anthony Buckeridge’s Jennings books (they get a mention), WE Johns’ Biggles series (they do too), Conan Doyle’s Sherlock short stories (again, briefly mentioned), and any number of True Story biographies about explorers.

It wasn’t until I was in my late teens that I began to read the books that are now considered the classic children’s books of that golden period — the Narnia books, The Borrowers sequence, Tom’s Midnight Garden etc.

By the way, my early and mid teen reading — my YA phase you could say — consisted of Ian Fleming, Mickey Spillane, George Orwell, Edna O’Brien, Francoise Sagan, Sartre, Simenon, Camus, Kerouac, to name a few.

In my first year at university (Keele) aged 18 in 1969, partly out of frustration that a general Foundation year had to be followed before my chosen subjects (English and American literature) could be studied in depth, and partly under the influence of contact with my then girlfriend (now my wife of over 50 years) I read all of the Narnia books, some of The Borrowers, TH White’s Mistress Macham’s Repose, and got heavily into George MacDonald (who, incidentally, is given a good amount of space in Leith’s book) and Celtic folktales.

It would be wrong of me to suggest that my childhood reading was entirely uninfluenced by any of the principal players in The Haunted Wood. I had a copy of Robert Louis Stevenson’s A Child’s Garden of Verses beside my bed and dipped into it regularly. I also loved Treasure Island. I thrilled to the power of narrative adventure when the teacher read John Buchan’s The 39 Steps aloud to us in the hut that we moved into when we were ten years old. (Leith acknowledges, viz a viz Hughes and Henty, that “the heart of the successful stuff is strorytelling and pace”). And my horror of ever finding a snake sliding in through an open window comes from Kipling’s Jungle Book stories. Leith’s chapter on Kipling is first-class.

Indeed, Leith is a wonderful writer throughout. People should read this book simply for the unalloyed pleasure of his commentaries on books they may or may not have read. I don’t believe I have ever properly experienced Thomas Hughes’ Tom Brown’s Schooldays, except for a short extract here and there. I intend now to put the book on my winter fireside reading list.

One of the things I like most about The Haunted Wood is that it takes itself and, when justified, its subject lightly. Footnotes are used to good effect. Early on, referring to and giving an apology in advance for the inevitability of omissions (I have no intention of complaining about the absence of any author in this review) he adds at the bottom of the page: “Unless it’s the Mr Men you are complaining about. Nuts to the Mr Men.”

In presenting this History of Childhood Reading, Leith has sought to write in the roles of literary historian (seeing how books have helped to shape one another), as literary critic (asking whether they’re any good and why) and as social historian (understanding how the books have shaped and engaged with the changing concept of childhood over time). He has succeeded in all three respects.

His turns of phrase can be piercingly accurate, as when referring to Quentin Blake’s “electrically expressive” drawings. He is not afraid to draw on contemporary references when seeking to convey the quality of older works. Basile’s The Tale of Tales, we are told, is more like South Park than Dora the Explorer. Beatrix Potter’s creatures are both sharply observed objects of nature and “furred and feathered avatars of bourgeois society”. Potter’s books are, he adds, “to use a literary-critical term, completely bananas”. (That made me smile.) CS Lewis is described as a “scruffy, beery, tweedy old geezer”. Watership Down features “a war that starts because a bunch of bunny-rabbits have blue balls. Silly, perhaps, but no less silly than the Iliad.” He muses that Dahl’s whangdoodles, hornswogglers and snozzwangers are like “refugees from the wilder corners of Pliny the Elder’s Natural History”.

There’s one other book that Leith has persuaded me that I must read — Nicholas Fisk’s 1973 novel, Grinny. When you come to read The Haunted Wood, as you must if you have any interest in children’s books, you will be persuaded to read others. Hopefully, many others.

Including books by Robert Cormier, despite Leith telling you that “There’s no poetry in Cormier.” There is. But it’s a poetry that has more in common with Cormac McCarthy than with Robert Louis Stevenson. The Chocolate War and Cormier’s other books were authentic YA novels, created for the kind of teenager that I was when I was resorting to adult fiction in the absence of anything written expressly for teenagers. And in that sense they never were conceived as “childhood reading”.

What has happened since, and this is explored to some degree by Leith when he writes about JK Rowling and Harry Potter, is that childhood reading has been extended into the teen years, and in some cases beyond that.

When I approached the rear of the book and saw a section on Picture Books looming, I feared it would feel like an unnecessary add-on. But its 30 odd pages are well worth their place and include a detailed appreciation of Julia Donaldson’s use of rhyme and rhythm.

Buy this book as a Christmas gift for anyone you know who has the slightest interest in the subject.

Just finished reading Sam Leith’s brilliant history of children’s reading, The Haunted Wood, and I can’t recommend it highly enough. Essential for anyone interested in #ChildrensBooks ! @questingvole @OneworldNews pic.twitter.com/GE5xiQQGsw

— Tony Bradman (@tbradman) October 7, 2024

Loved the book, The Haunted Wood, and discussing children’s authors processing their own trauma, what Winnie the Pooh owed to Alice in Wonderland, how it takes a generation to process a war, the darkness of Robert Cormier, and whether Mary Poppins was a grumpy piece of work … https://t.co/vzGB5mWjrt

— Nicolette Jones (@NicoletteJones) September 10, 2024

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Related

Filed Under: BookOfTheDay, BookOfTheYear, Gift, NonFiction Tagged With: books, childhood, criticism, history, literature, reading, survey

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright ACHUKA © 2026 · designed on Genesis Framework

Loading Comments...