on age-banding, given at this weekend's conference in Cambirdge.
Read every word.
No to Age Banding: Philip Pullman's address
Categories:
2 Comments
Leave a comment
Pages
About this Entry
This page contains a single entry by achuka published on September 1, 2008 7:13 PM.
Socks away! Roald Dahl's wartime sex raids - Times Online was the previous entry in this blog.
Booktrust Teenage Prize Shortlist is the next entry in this blog.
Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.
Categories
- ACHUKA (2222)
- ACHUKAbooks (53)
- Adult (2)
- apps (22)
- Auctions (10)
- Australasia (117)
- Awards (512)
- Canada (102)
- Cats (2)
- Competitions (28)
- Conferences (14)
- Cricket (2)
- Deals (44)
- Diary (11)
- eBooks (80)
- Europe (9)
- Fairs/Festivals (36)
- Films/TV (161)
- Flickr (5)
- Gaming (1)
- Garden (4)
- howabout (31)
- Illustration (166)
- Interview (83)
- Jazz (2)
- Jobs (2)
- Launches / Events (45)
- Manga (16)
- Obituaries (168)
- Poetry (40)
- Publicity & Marketing (4)
- Reviews (1086)
- Trailer (13)
- US (256)
- Web Design (6)
- Wiki (1)
Monthly Archives
- January 2013 (21)
- December 2012 (47)
- November 2012 (51)
- October 2012 (62)
- September 2012 (42)
- August 2012 (33)
- July 2012 (61)
- June 2012 (38)
- May 2012 (58)
- April 2012 (41)
- March 2012 (106)
- February 2012 (72)
- January 2012 (66)
- December 2011 (58)
- November 2011 (44)
- October 2011 (48)
- September 2011 (37)
- August 2011 (10)
- July 2011 (41)
- June 2011 (47)
- May 2011 (42)
- April 2011 (34)
- March 2011 (44)
- February 2011 (40)
- January 2011 (27)
- December 2010 (17)
- November 2010 (46)
- October 2010 (48)
- September 2010 (65)
- August 2010 (20)
- July 2010 (22)
- June 2010 (15)
- May 2010 (28)
- April 2010 (26)
- March 2010 (27)
- February 2010 (27)
- January 2010 (23)
- December 2009 (14)
- November 2009 (36)
- October 2009 (27)
- September 2009 (32)
- August 2009 (33)
- July 2009 (41)
- June 2009 (38)
- May 2009 (30)
- April 2009 (34)
- March 2009 (39)
- February 2009 (29)
- January 2009 (30)
- December 2008 (25)
- November 2008 (59)
- October 2008 (55)
- September 2008 (29)
- August 2008 (44)
- July 2008 (27)
- June 2008 (50)
- May 2008 (23)
- April 2008 (32)
- March 2008 (50)
- February 2008 (27)
- January 2008 (31)
- December 2007 (11)
- November 2007 (19)
- October 2007 (24)
- September 2007 (38)
- August 2007 (8)
- July 2007 (49)
- June 2007 (41)
- May 2007 (44)
- April 2007 (35)
- March 2007 (44)
- February 2007 (28)
- January 2007 (50)
- December 2006 (34)
- November 2006 (40)
- October 2006 (41)
- September 2006 (43)
- August 2006 (38)
- July 2006 (42)
- June 2006 (60)
- May 2006 (55)
- April 2006 (38)
- March 2006 (60)
- February 2006 (40)
- January 2006 (63)
- December 2005 (57)
- November 2005 (63)
- October 2005 (60)
- September 2005 (70)
- August 2005 (63)
- July 2005 (68)
- June 2005 (57)
- May 2005 (34)
- April 2005 (64)
- March 2005 (65)
- February 2005 (56)
- January 2005 (77)
- December 2004 (63)
- November 2004 (75)
- October 2004 (63)
- September 2004 (62)
- August 2004 (61)
- July 2004 (89)
- June 2004 (68)
- May 2004 (81)
- April 2004 (83)
- March 2004 (79)
- February 2004 (76)
- January 2004 (83)
- December 2003 (67)
- November 2003 (97)
- October 2003 (57)
- September 2003 (45)
- August 2003 (36)
- July 2003 (52)
- June 2003 (79)
- May 2003 (62)
- April 2003 (27)
OpenID accepted here
Learn more about OpenID
I've always been a _huge_ admirer of Kate Wilson. I read this report too and, as far as I could gather, Kate expressed an informal personal response which acknowledged that publishers had handled the situation rather badly, especially in regard to not seeking the views of authors first. There was no indication or suggestion that she rebutted in any substantial way the other objections made in Philip Pullman's address.
But if Kate is indeed fully in favour of age-banding, I can't envisage a more intriguing two-way debate than a head-to-head between Philip Pullman and Kate Wilson. I'm sure it would make great television!
I read in Julia Eccleshare's Guardian article this morning that Kate Wilson presented a fair, interesting and informed response to the age-guidance discussion that actually echoes the opinions of a lot of people in the children's book trade. There is no mention of this here - only a link to Anne Fine's address, which as we all know, very much echoes that of Philip Pullman's.