Back to main page...

Reviewers


Dina Rabinovitch writes about children's literature for The Guardian


Jake Hope works for the library service co-ordinating the Lancashire Children?s Book of the Year Award. He has a wide-ranging interest in children?s books and has studied for an MA in International Children?s Literature.


Mai Lin Li works as a librarian in West Yorkshire.


Patrick Cave writes Young Adult fiction. Blown Away, the sequel to Sharp North, is his most recent title.


When not immersed in a book, Rowan Stanfield can usually be found playing an eclectic selection of music at her stereo (or recently aquired DJ decks)


Alastair Ray is a freelance journalist who has written regularly for the Financial Times, The Guardian, Media Week and Marketing.


Abbie Todd is a third year undergraduate at the University of East Anglia, Norwich studying English Literature with Creative Writing. She works part time in the children's department of Ottakar's, Norwich


Dawn Casey's background is in children?s publishing and primary education. She is the author of several picture books.


Kate Wright is currently researching Joan Aiken's ?Wolves of Willoughby Chase? novels for an MA dissertation in Children?s Literature at Roehampton University.


Michael Thorn is the founding editor of ACHUKA. He is the author of a biography of Tennyson (Little Brown) and has contributed to numerous reference books, including the New DNB. He writes for TES, The Scotsman and Literary Review.

all reviews by Michael Thorn

March 1, 2008

Airman

Eoin Colfer
Puffin
9780141383354
Jan 2008
"One of my childhood favorites was The Princess Bride [by William Goldman]. Read that to see how I was influenced by his pacing and the swashbuckling tone he set there while being quite humorous. That's one of the finest examples of a high adventure book," Eoin Colfer says in a recent interview with the magazine Newsweek.
Airman is a fabulous mix of adventure, high daring and romance. There are comic moments, but these are lowkey compared with the emphasis on high adventure. Colfer has already achieved fame and fortune with his Artemis Fowl novels. With Airman he will have achieved new stature and respect for his abilities as an author.
With each turn of the page the quality and pitch of the writing seems to ratchet up an extra notch until, in the last section of the book, it feels to me that Colfer is writing at the the very peak of his abilities, skillfully maintaining tension and excitement while repeating scenes from different points of view.
He has produced a work of literally marvellous escapism, and selected a real-life setting (The Saltees) perfect for his requirement.
Very highly recommended for confident readers aged 9+.

February 20, 2007

The Astonishing Life Of Octavian Nothing

M. T. Anderson
Candlewick Books
0763624020
Jan 2007
An outstanding novel.

The first of two volumes, its full title is The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Traitor To The Nation - Volume 1: The Pox Party. I already tell everyone I meet to read this author's fantastic satirical novel, Feed, and now I shall be telling them to read this.
I dare say young readers - especially those unfamiliar with Feed and Anderson's other novels - may struggle to get into it, fearful that the formal eighteenth century diction and grammar of Octavian's narrative might never develop into a compelling story. But they will soon be fascinated by the narrator's realtionship with his young teenage mother and by all the goings-on at the College of Lucidity, where Octavian is treated to a trial education of letters and manners.

Eventually both the boy and the mother fall victim to another trial involving smallpox. Dr Trefusis observes at one point during this harrowing section of the book, "When I peer into the reaches of the most distant futurity, I fear that even in some unseen epock when there are colonies even upon the moon itself, there shall still be gatherings like this, where the young, blinded by privilege, shall dance and giggle and compare their poxy legions." It is just that 'most distant futurity' which Andersen describes (in a far different prose) in Feed.

Octavian's own narrative comes to an abrupt halt three quarters of the way through the novel, at a moment of great heartbreak, and it is a tribute to Andersen's skill and confidence as a stylist that the miscellany of documents and correspondence that fills most of the remaining part of this first volume holds the reader riveted until Octavian's return.

I haven't mentioned yet that Octavian is a black child born to an African mother; that the book is about slavery and the events leading up to the War of Independence. Those are the themes. And Andersen's book will remain a classic treatment of slavery and the birth of the American nation for a very long time to come.





January 16, 2007

DOWN TO THE WIRE

Bernard Ashley
Orchard Books
1846160596
Oct 2006
If I were still a teacher, this book would be a tempting choice to get my class engaged in a whole number of fields. Geography, history, current affairs and politics, evolving use of English language… any of these might be approached through DOWN TO THE WIRE. We’re in West Africa here; a fictitious but very recognisable country somewhere in the region of Nigeria and Ghana. Near the coast we have the wealthier part of the nation, the government, the dominant tribe, the strongest western influences. Inland, we have poorer, often-resentful tribal minorities, sharing their cultural and religious allegiances with those in neighbouring countries rather than with their own government and fellow citizens. Yet, as in so many west African states, the nation’s wealth is dependent on one or two commodities. It might be oil, or precious metals, or cocoa: in this case it is HEP, generated through a vast inland dam project (surely modelled on the Volta) and providing power that can be sold abroad, as well as driving domestic industry. But, typically, this resource lies within the territory of the tribal minorities. So when the question of independence for these minorities comes up, the government eyes its precious resource and is more than a little dismayed. It’s a model that recurs constantly, one made possible by western colonization, non-tribal borders and further interference long after any occupying power has fled. The reliance on single resources and erosion of traditional subsistence economies, the wish to exploit natural resources, the wish to sell arms to both the minority ‘freedom fighters’ (themselves often sponsored or controlled by fellow tribesmen in other countries) and to the governing troops, the demented wish to sell nuclear technology to unstable powers (is there any other sort?)… this is what drives the western take on so many developing countries. So, into this bubbling mess drop Ben Maddox, a UK reporter, sent with his cameraman by a canny news editor to get a scoop on possible war and humanitarian catastrophe. Add also a promising young footballer, one of the tribal minority, under conflicting pressures to make his name on the lucrative world stage and to stick by his cultural and religious roots, to keep excellence at home. Stir in a ‘terror’ group that kidnaps children to turn them into soldiers. As a finishing touch add Israelis and others, possibly sniffing out a nuclear market; an Irish ex-football star, ostensibly talent-scouting; a western mercenary, with his eyes on power and wealth. Ashley’s real coup here is that he sets this all up and makes it totally accessible to a teen audience, spinning an easy-read thriller-type plot that is told through e-mails, news reports, the diary of a kidnapped girl, football commentaries and texts, as well as short chunks of traditional narrative. Some of the main characters are a tad two-dimensional or unengaging – there is a whiff of the boys’ adventure stories of yesteryear - but as a whole, the book is gripping and sickeningly realistic as we watch Ben and his colleague get drawn steadily across the line that keeps newspeople ‘neutral’. A recommended, original read, tweaked from four to five chicks by its huge relevance.





November 4, 2006

Close-Up

Close-Up by Sherry Ashworth
Simon & Schuster
1416904743
September 2006
Told in alternate chapters by Jimmy and Liz, co-workers at the Coffee Corp coffee bar, this is a richly compelling novel of interpesonal and family relationships. If there is not much that is original about the subject matter - broken parental relationships with a suddenly reappeared father on the one hand, and a less than enthusiastically received new partner on the other - there is much that is admirable in the way the author depicts the developing relationship between her two main characters. My heart sank temporarily three-quarters of the way through when what appeared to be an unnecessary issue-based element entered the narrative but this proved to have important implications for both Jimmy and Liz and was therefore integral to the storyline. Film fans will enjoy the freqent references Jimmy makes to set scenes from movies. There have been other books featuring movie-obsessed characters, but few of them have so successfully conveyed the way such an obsession affects a character's inner monologue. Particularly effective are those passages in which Jimmy predicts the way a pending encounter is likely to go. Also highly effective is the way Ashworth uses the coffee-bar workplace, rather than school or college, as the main venue for her teenage characters.



November 29, 2005

Clay

David Almond
Hodder
184509487X
Nov 2005
Since Counting Stars (a short story collection that can be viewed as a 'Dubliners' of the North-East), David Almond's fiction has been set in the time of his own childhood, growing directly out of experiences he had as a young boy. In some ways there is a marked difference between this latest novel and early books like Skellig and Kit's WIlderness. But the similarities are there too: the immaculate writing; the strange, mysterious individual, possessor of special powers, at the fulcrum of the story; the sense of menace; the intervening magic.

It did seem (I'm of the same generation as Almond) that there were a greater number of deranged, demented and scarifying individuals at large in the community in the late 1950s and early 1960s. More than one character in this book would, in a contemporary novel, have been counselled or (more likely) drugged into comparative quietude. This, coupled with the freedom that children had to wander around from dawn till dusk without parental paranoia (it really was like that then) makes it the perfect period to write about.

Almond's fiction is special because it has a religious or spiritual layer. The main characters in this book are altar boys who, with typical adolescent mundanity, view their duties (at weddings and funerals) in the same regard as waiters serving at table, with an eye on the best tip. The damaged character is one who has been rejected by the Roman Catholic seminary, and yet, moulding figures out of clay, seems to have the divine power of investing the inanimate with life.

Like all great books, Clay contains tragedy, hope and a sense of right (or down-to-earth goodness) being wronged. It's a reminder, if reminder is needed, that David Almond is the very best author at work in the field of YA fiction in the UK.

This is the first title on ACHUKAREVIEWS to be awarded five GOLD achukachiks.



November 16, 2005

Outside In - Children's Books In Translation

Deborah Hallford & Edgardo Zaghini
Milet
184509487X
Nov 2005
What a tremendous resource this is. It opens, after a short introduction by the editors and foreword by Philip Pullman, with a series of articles by a reviewer (Nick Tucker), a translator (Sarah Adams), an author (Lene Kaaberbol), an academic (Gillian Lathey), a publisher (Kalus Flugge) and others. Then there are the book recommendations themselves, organised in five age categories plus graphic novels, non-fiction, and dual language books. The last quarter of the book is given over to author and illustrator biographies and helpful resource and organisation details. Finally, there is a very good index.

Most guides of this type have to be produced on a shoestring of a budget and often appear in dowdy pamphlet format. This one has been designed and produced to an extremely high standard (it has benefitted from Arts Council sponsorship), with cover and inside illustrations by Pablo Bernasconi. An essential resource for anyone seriously interested in giving children the widest access to all that's best in children's books from around the world. More than being a handy signpost to what's available today, this bright user-friendly production ought to serve as an incentive for publishers to produce an increasing number of books in translation in the future.



November 14, 2005

Wenceslas

ill. Christian Birmingham text by Geraldine McCaughrean
Doubleday
0385605358
Nov 2005
I stupidly over-wrote this review when adding a new one. If someone has my original words saved in any format I'd be grateful if they could send them to me so that they can be reinstated. What I remember saying is roughly this: McCaughrean's text (taking its cues from J. M. Neale's well-known carol) is pitch perfect from the start: "So great fires were burning in every palace grate, and twelve days of Christmas feasting lay ahead, silly with song and dance!" Don't you just love that 'silly'?

But it's Christian Birmingham's illustrations that really drive this retelling of the King and the pageboy's charitable visit to a peasant's home. The only other illustrator I can imagine coming near to Birmingham's rich evocation of that peasant-King gathering is P J Lynch. In the following pageturn, revealing such a contrasting scene - a cold aerial view of the snow-smothered cottage and surrounding forest, we see an illustrator at work who really knows how to drive a narrative forward pictorially.

The best new Christmas title of 2005.



November 8, 2005

Tamar

Mal Peet
Walker
0744565707
Oct 2005
I've just done that thing you do when you turn the last page on an exceptionally good book. Close the back cover, stare gormlessly at the jacket illustration and make a cross between a sniff and a sigh. The sniff for appreciation of great work done, the sigh of regret that a story you've savoured has finished.

Mal Peet's first novel, Keeper, was a miracle. A novel that finally revealed to me - a cricket lover - the poetry and magic in the game of soccer. Second novels are often disappointments, and when the author himself told me (at a summer party) that he was working on a novel set in Holland during the war, I confess I felt disappointment was on the cards.

How wrong. This is an outstanding novel. Outstanding in every regard. It establishes Peet as a novelist of immense gift and versatility, for no two novels could be more different than Keeper and Tamar and yet be so equally brilliant.

The two principal characters in Tamar are undercover operators working in Nazi-occupied Holland in support of the resistance. There is many an episode of nailbiting excitement in the book, but for much of the time the undercover agents have to cope with the boredom of waiting and watching, and with the interpersonal tension of loving the same woman.

Parallel to this is a more contemporary narrative, set in 1995, which is properly subservient to the war story, and yet utterly convincing.

Throughout the book the writing is of the highest order, crisply figurative description falling from Peet's pen with apparent ease: "the mud had solidified into frost-capped peaks and ripples that looked like mountain ranges seen from the cockpit of an aircraft" or "the sky was the colour on old knife" to give just two examples.

Published by Walker Books as a Young Adult novel, Tamar is a novel worthy of standing with the very best of contemporary British fiction.





October 16, 2005

Chasing Vermeer

Blue Baillet ill. by Brett Helquist
The Chicken House
1904442714
Oct 2005
What an excellent concoction this is! Especially recommended for that group of children referred to by the rather unpleasant phrase 'gifted and talented'. It's a book for the thinking reader, for the reader who likes puzzles and mysteries. It's also a book that will make teachers who slavishly follow schemes of work think carefully about becoming more like Ms Hussey, the novel's wonderfully spur-of-the-moment teacher.

The book uses pentominoes (a set of 12 tessellating shapes each comprising five squares) as a model for the way apparently unconnected events can be made to interlock and lead to the solution of a mystery. The central relationship between Petra and Calder is somewhat serious and geeky but works well and the moody black-and-white fullpage illustrations by Brett Helquist make a huge contribution to the novel's atmosphere.